Key takeaways
- The best questions to ask a marketing agency are about who does the work, how they measure success, and what happens when results drop.
- Good answers are specific to your business, name the metric they will be judged on, and admit what they need from you.
- Ask to see a real report and a sample audit finding, because how an agency explains numbers tells you more than its case studies.
- Make sure you own the ad accounts, pixels, analytics and data before any contract starts, so you can leave without losing history.
The most useful questions to ask a marketing agency are not about awards or tools. They are about who will run your account day to day, which number they will be judged on, how they measure it, and what they do when results drop. Good answers are specific to your business; weak answers sound like they could be sent to any client.
Below are fifteen of them, grouped by topic, each with what a good answer sounds like and what should make you pause.
Why do the questions matter more than the pitch deck?
Every agency has a polished deck. Case studies are chosen to impress, and logos say little about who did the work or under what conditions. What separates agencies is how they think, and that shows up when they answer questions they did not prepare for.
When you are hiring a marketing agency, you are really hiring a small group of people and a way of working. The questions below test both. Use them on the first call, then again when you review the proposal. If you are still deciding between building a team or outsourcing, read in-house vs agency vs freelancer first.
Questions about who does the work
1. Who exactly will work on my account, and how senior are they? Good: names roles, says who you will talk to weekly and who builds campaigns. The people on the call are the people on the account. Pause: "Our team" with no names, or a senior strategist who disappears after signing.
“Ask how they handle a bad month. That answer is the real pitch.”
2. How many accounts does each person handle? Good: a clear answer and an explanation of how they protect time for your account. Pause: vagueness. A manager spread across too many brands cannot test properly.
3. What do you need from us to succeed? Good: a specific list. Access, a decision maker, product and margin data, fast creative approvals, backend numbers. Pause: "Nothing, we handle everything." Performance depends on both sides.
Questions about tracking and measurement
4. Which metric will you be judged on? Good: one primary metric tied to your business, such as CAC, ROAS, cost per qualified lead or orders, plus a few supporting metrics. Pause: impressions, reach or clicks as the headline result for a sales or leads goal.
5. How will you check our tracking before spending more? Good: they describe an audit of events, deduplication, and reconciliation against your backend or CRM. We explain our process in tracking audit before scaling ads. Pause: they plan to launch campaigns first and "look at tracking later."
6. What source of truth will you report against? Good: your backend orders, paid bookings or qualified leads, with platform numbers shown alongside. Pause: only screenshots from Ads Manager.
7. Can you show me a real report you send to a client? Good: an anonymised report with clear commentary, decisions taken and next steps. Pause: a dashboard full of charts and no explanation of what changed or why.
Questions about strategy and platforms
8. What would you do in the first 30 days? Good: audit, fix tracking, restructure, set up a testing plan, agree targets. A sequence with reasons. Pause: "Launch new campaigns in week one" before anyone has looked at the data.
9. How do you decide how to split budget across channels? Good: by each channel's role and marginal cost per result, reviewed regularly, with room for testing. Pause: a fixed split that never changes, or "whatever the platform recommends."
10. How do you approach creative? Good: a testing system, a view on how many concepts per month, and who produces them. On Meta and TikTok in particular, creative drives most of the results. Pause: "Send us your assets and we will run them."
11. What would make you tell us not to spend more? Good: a straight answer, for example broken tracking, a weak landing page, poor margins or no stock. An agency willing to advise less spend is thinking about your business. Pause: every answer leads to a bigger budget.
Questions about reporting, contracts and exit
12. Who owns the ad accounts, pixels and data? Good: you do. The agency works inside your Business Manager, Google Ads account, GA4 and GTM with partner access. Pause: accounts created under the agency's name with no clear handover.
13. How often do we meet and what happens in those meetings? Good: a set rhythm, for example weekly short check-ins and a monthly review with decisions. Pause: monthly PDF only, no conversation.
14. What is the minimum term, and how do we exit? Good: a clear minimum term with a reason, a notice period, and a written handover process. Pause: long lock-ins with no performance review points, or no answer at all.
15. What went wrong on a past account and what did you change? Good: an honest story, a specific lesson, a process they changed because of it. Pause: "Nothing has ever gone wrong."
A quick checklist you can use on agency calls
| Area | Question to ask | What good sounds like | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| Team | Who runs my account? | Named roles, seniors stay on | Bait and switch after signing |
| Metric | What are you judged on? | CAC, ROAS or qualified leads | Reach and clicks as the headline |
| Tracking | How will you verify data? | Audit plus backend reconciliation | "We trust the platform numbers" |
| Plan | First 30 days? | Audit, fix, structure, test plan | Launch first, think later |
| Creative | How do you test? | Concepts per month, clear process | "Send us your assets" |
| Ownership | Who owns accounts and data? | You, with partner access | Agency owned accounts |
| Exit | How do we leave? | Notice period and handover | Long lock-in, no review points |
Give each row a 1 to 3. Look hardest at tracking and ownership, because an agency that is weak there will struggle however good the creative looks.
How we answer these questions at FOXA
Here are our own answers in short. The senior people you meet on the first call stay on your account, and we are judged on CAC, ROAS and qualified leads, and we report against your backend, not only platform dashboards.
Most engagements start with a 7 to 10 day audit, credited to month one if you continue. Paid media retainers have a three-month minimum because that is how long setup, learning and real optimisation take. You own every account and every pixel from day one. You can see our full scope on our services and our FAQ.
Some outcomes from that way of working: for HappyFresh, new-user CAC fell 69% in 3 months after we rebuilt iOS measurement (the story). For Pintarnya, Meta cost per registration dropped 68% and registrations grew 3.6x. For Cosmart, cost per order fell 45%.
If you are still comparing options, our guide on how to choose a digital marketing agency in Jakarta covers the shortlist stage.
Bring these questions to your next call
Take this list into your next agency conversation and notice who answers with specifics. If you want to test us with it, book a call and ask us any of the fifteen.
Questions we get asked
How many marketing agencies should I talk to before choosing one?
Three to four is usually enough. Fewer and you have nothing to compare against; more and the calls blur together. Send each agency the same short brief with your goal, current channels and the metric you care about, then compare how specifically each one responds. The quality of their questions back to you is a strong early signal.
What should a marketing agency proposal include?
A useful proposal restates your goal and main metric, explains what they would do in the first 30 to 90 days, names the people on the account, lists what they need from you, and describes the reporting rhythm. It should also explain the pricing model and contract terms clearly. A proposal full of generic service descriptions and no plan for your business is a weak sign.
Is it a red flag if an agency guarantees a specific ROAS?
Usually, yes. ROAS depends on your margins, pricing, product, landing page, tracking and market, much of which the agency does not control. A credible agency will share targets based on your data and past work, explain the assumptions, and agree on how progress is reviewed. A guaranteed number before anyone has looked at your account is a sales line, not a plan.
How long does it take to see results from a new marketing agency?
For paid media, expect the first month to go into audit, tracking fixes and restructuring, with clearer performance trends in months two and three. SEO and content take longer, often several months before traffic moves. That is why many performance agencies, including us, ask for a minimum three-month paid media commitment: it covers setup, learning and real optimisation.
About FOXA DigitalFOXA Digital is a performance marketing agency in Jakarta, Indonesia. Since 2018 we have run paid media, tracking, SEO and content for apps, consumer brands, hospitality and attractions, judged on CAC, ROAS and leads.
Want us to look at your numbers?
30 minutes. No deck. You leave with three things to fix this week.



